Carter Dickson Top Five (Sir Henry Merrivale)

There’s been a bit of discussion on the Big Finish message board about the potential to adapt John Dickson Carr/Carter Dickson’s work, so I thought it would be nice to do a couple of top fives, one for each “author”. Generally speaking, the books written under the Dickson by-line are more overtly humorous than the Carr ones, Sir Henry Merrivale in particular acting like nothing less than a clown at times. I think, in general, I prefer the Dickson novels, which is why I thought I’d do these first.

1.       The Judas Window

Imagine waking up, the last thing you remember being an argument with your future father-in-law, to find him stabbed in the heart with a crossbow bolt in a room completely sealed from the inside. Not the best start to your day, obviously. Told mostly in flashback as Sir Henry Merrivale decides to defend the accused in court, this is one of the greats of Golden Age detective fiction. Get searching on Abebooks and get yourself a copy of this. You won’t regret it.

2.       The Reader is Warned

Don’t be put off by the weird title, this is a tale of psychic powers – allegedly. A guest at a dinner predicts that the host will drop dead at a given time. Later that night, his prediction comes true – the host is dead without a mark on his body. Set just before the outbreak of the Second World War, part of the book deals with the hysteria around the possibility of such a psychic weapon. Merrivale is on hand to sort it out, providing the simple but elegant solution.

3.       She Died A Lady

When an ignored wife and her lover disappear, everyone assumes that they’ve committed suicide. After all, their footprints lead to a cliff-top and then just vanish over the edge. No other footprints are nearby. Merrivale gets involved when the bodies are found, both having been shot from close range. One of the best written of the Merrivale books, both in plot and in characterisation.

4.       Nine – and Death Makes Ten aka Murder in the Submarine Zone

Another wartime story (Carr/Dickson really wrote his best stuff in the forties) set on a ship crossing the Atlantic, under risk of German attack. When someone is murdered on the ship, suspicion obviously falls on the nine other people on board. But the murderer left a fingerprint that matches none of the nine. (If you’re wondering, the solution ISN’T that someone is very good at hiding). Very atmospheric and a nice mystery.

5.       The Red Widow Murders

An early Merrivale, it tells of a legend of a haunted room in which no-one who stays in it alone will survive the night. Needless to say, someone tries it and is dead the next morning, poisoned by curare. But there are no marks on the body, so how did he die – curare needs to be introduced directly into the bloodstream, and there isn’t a mark on the body. An atmospheric mystery with ingenious solutions to both the modern day murder and the legend that inspired it.

To avoid – most of the Merrivale stories are a lot of fun, but the later ones, especially Behind the Crimson Blind are lacking the spark of the earlier stories.

An extra mention must go to the only Merrivale short story, The House in Goblin Wood. It’s been reprinted in a few different places, so keep an eye out for it – it’s truly excellent. There’s also the novella All In A Maze, which is good fun.

EXTRA: I’ve started an index of my Carter Dickson reviews here.

About Puzzle Doctor

I'm a mathematician by nature and as such have always been drawn to the logical side of things. Hence my two main hobbies being classic mysteries and logical puzzling. Oh, and cats. No logic there, I'm afraid.
This entry was posted in Carter Dickson, Locked Rooms and Impossible Murders, Short Stories, Sir Henry Merrivale, Top Fives. Bookmark the permalink.

20 Responses to Carter Dickson Top Five (Sir Henry Merrivale)

  1. bianco2nero says:

    Just came across your blog over at the Big Finish Forum – many congrats for an excellent site. I think TEN TEACUPS (aka PEACOCK FEATHER MYSTERY) might rate a little higher than NINE AND DEATH but I have a huge affection for that one too as it was the second Carter Dickson I ever read, the first being the often unjustly neglected THE READER IS WARNED.


    • puzzledoctor says:

      Many thanks for the kind words.

      I do rate the Ten Teacups highly as well – it’s one of the better ones that I didn’t mention along with The White Priory Murders and He Wouldn’t Kill Patience – but the solution is so bizarre, that marks it down for me.

      I think THE READER IS WARNED is my favourite as well, as that was my first Dickson as well.

      Hope you keep reading – there will be a John Dickson Carr top five in the next day or so, once I decide what they are.


  2. Pingback: My Favourite Mysteries – Part One | In Search of the Classic Mystery Novel

  3. Pingback: Mysteries for Younger Readers | In Search of the Classic Mystery Novel

  4. Pingback: The Bride of Newgate by John Dickson Carr | In Search of the Classic Mystery Novel

  5. Pingback: The House In Goblin Wood by Carter Dickson | In Search of the Classic Mystery Novel

  6. Pingback: Nine – And Death Makes Ten, aka Murder In The Submarine Zone by Carter Dickson | In Search of the Classic Mystery Novel

  7. Pingback: Series or Standalone? | In Search of the Classic Mystery Novel

  8. Rishi Arora says:

    finished reading The Reader is Warned on YOUR recommendation, thank you for suggesting this book. It is one of Carr’s best


  9. Rishi Arora says:

    trying to find nine and death makes ten, really difficult to get Carr’s old books in India.


  10. Pingback: The Red Widow Murders by Carter Dickson | In Search of the Classic Mystery Novel

  11. Pingback: Paul Doherty Top Five – my 300th Post | In Search of the Classic Mystery Novel

  12. Pingback: The Curse Of The Bronze Lamp aka Lord of the Sorcerors by Carter Dickson aka John Dickson Carr | In Search of the Classic Mystery Novel

  13. The post is over two years old and I’ve just realised that He Wouldn’t Kill Patience really should be at number five… oops.


  14. Pingback: Doc On The Box – Jonathan Creek – The Clue Of The Savant’s Thumb | In Search of the Classic Mystery Novel

  15. Pingback: Castle Skull by John Dickson Carr | In Search of the Classic Mystery Novel

  16. Pingback: Top Five Underappreciated Books – My 600th Post | In Search of the Classic Mystery Novel

  17. And now, having reviewed My Late Wives, I can’t help feeling that it deserves a place here too… decisions, decisions…


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s