The Midnight Man by Paul Doherty

Chaucer’s pilgrims have once again stopped for the night and it’s time for the physician to tell his tale of mystery and murder. Oddly, there’s not a doctor in sight in his tale of Brother Anselm and his novice Stephen who are summoned to a church in Candlewick to perform an exorcism. The spirits have been unleashed by the notorious Midnight Man, a mysterious masked warlock, but why have they been unleashed? Are there other motives at work other than raising spirits for the fun of it? And was it the spirits who threw someone off the deserted church tower, or stabbed someone inside the locked church? Or is an earthly hand helping matters along?

It’s been ten years since A Haunt of Murder, the sixth in the Canterbury Tales series, and one wonders why there was such a wait before Paul Doherty returned to the series. In some ways, it holds the most potential of any of his series as he can basically write stand-alone stories under a series banner, and, as we’ve established before, the style of the stories – ghost stories, historical conspiracies, murder mysteries – can vary much more so that a series with a regular sleuth. So, how does this, the seventh in the series stand up to what has gone before?

Well, it’s certainly close to the best of the series, but as we’ve also established before, I don’t see eye to eye with some of my fellow reviewers – notably Patrick – on which are the best in series, so that probably doesn’t mean much.

Clearly from the set-up, we’re talking real ghosts and demons here in part, and certainly the opening sections, concerning the first attempted exorcism of the church, are chilling. The ghosts come and go thereafter and while there are other creepy sections, nothing came close to emulating the opening for me. It seems that exorcisms are something the writer does well – there’s another one in A Haunt of Murder that is just as creepy. Thereafter, the ghosts mostly appear to remind you there’s a threat rather than actually doing an awful lot. Because it’s quite clear that the mystery that you’re supposed to be interested in is the identity and motives of the Midnight Man.

The other strand running through the book is the story of the Crown Jewels Robbery of 1303, as Richard Puddlicot, the thief in question, hid a fair portion of the loot, and it’s clear that this is important. The Robbery itself is also important to the author as well, having authored a book on it and also featuring Puddlicot himself in Murder Wears A Cowl. Well, it seems that after Hugh Corbett caught him in that book, bad things happened.

As is often the case with Doherty’s books, there’s a pretty high body count here as the Midnight Man ups his game, and after a while it began reading more like a thriller. While the identity of the warlock is written as a mystery, the revelation of it seemed less important to the story.

In fact I was thinking about this the other day – what makes a good mystery? What I came up with was a simple idea – did I, at any point, put the book down to have a think about what was going on? I’ll be honest here – I really enjoyed the book, but at no time did I feel the need to have a little ponder on the events happening therein. Also, once the villain stands revealed, there were no little bits where I mentally kicked myself for not spotting something – although there are clues, and, to be fair, I did like the mechanism for the locked church mystery.

So, to conclude, a strong contribution to the series – not up there with A Haunt of Murder or The Hangman’s Hymn, but an entertaining page-turner, even if the mystery itself didn’t quite grab me. Recommended – but you might need to pester your library to get a copy.

About these ads

About Puzzle Doctor

I'm a mathematician by nature and as such have always been drawn to the logical side of things. Hence my two main hobbies being classic mysteries and logical puzzling. Oh, and cats. No logic there, I'm afraid.
This entry was posted in Historical Fiction Challenge, Historical Mysteries, Locked Rooms and Impossible Murders, Paul Doherty. Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to The Midnight Man by Paul Doherty

  1. Patrick says:

    Sounds like great fun — I ordered a signed copy of it a few days ago, so we’ll see when it arrives!

    • FYI didn’t spot any obvious spoilers for the ones you haven’t read. There is a bit more knight-monk glowering but that’s about it.

      • Patrick says:

        Thanks for that. I was actually hoping to get to read the Canterbury Tales fully before this one was released, but when I saw that you were doing that I decided to let you have first crack. Still, A HAUNT OF MURDER and THE HANGMAN’S HYMN sound like absolute gems, and this one sounds pretty damn cool too! Gotta love Doherty!

  2. richmcd says:

    These sound fun! Although I’d be leery about combining the supernatural with ‘impossible’ crimes. How does the reader know which parts need to be unravelled and which parts are just magic?

    Out of interest, is the person being thrown off the church tower an impossible crime? Or just the stabbing in the church?

    • It’s made reasonably clear where the line is drawn between the supernatural and the human aspect. As for the tower… There’s a bit of “how did the killer get up there” but no real impossibility raised here.

  3. Hi Steve, have ou read this article on the BBC news site on the enduring popularity of the locked room mystery? Paul Doherty is right there in pole position: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-18108498. It is partly a promo for a documentary to be broadcast later today on Radio 4 in which comedian Miles Jupp discusses the genre. More details here: http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01hw6h8

  4. Pingback: The Puzzly – The ISOTCMN Book of the Month – May 2012 | In Search of the Classic Mystery Novel

  5. Pingback: Paul Doherty Top Five – my 300th Post | In Search of the Classic Mystery Novel

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s