The Door Between by Ellery Queen

And so, to the demand of absolutely no-one, I return to my bibliography of reviews of the novels of Ellery Queen, aka Fred Dannay and Manfred Lee, after too long a break, caused almost completely by the discovery of Paul Doherty.

In The Door Between, we have one of the few locked room mysteries in the canon – Eva Maclure is waiting outside Karen Leith’s room for a long time – she can clearly hear her in there, initially at least, but when a ringing phone goes unanswered, she enters the room only to discover Leith dead on the floor with her throat cut and no other exits to the room, apart from a door bolted on the inside. The windows are all barred, so how did the killer escape?

There are a number of interesting things to say about this one, which I will proceed to do. But the all-important question is, is it any good? To be honest, I’m not entirely sure…

First thing to point out is that Ellery seems pretty normal in this one – very few, if any, of his overly verbose exclamations – he just seems like a pleasantly normal chap. It is possibly that this is because most of the book is seem through the eyes of Eva Maclure, and maybe she edits out the nonsense, but the book isn’t narrated by her – we just see her point of view of events for the scenes that she is present in – which is most of them.

There’s a good reason for this, in that we need to know that Eva, the only conceivable suspect for the police, is innocent. There’s basically no evidence for such a belief, until Ellery reveals the truth at the end of the book, so we need a mechanism to dismiss this solution as quickly as possible. Unfortunately this is such a clinical locked room that once you dismiss Eva, there isn’t really any other possibility apart from the truth – the writers lock the room too well and I expect the majority of the readers will be disappointed with the solution. I was – at least when a similar method was applied to another book that I read quite recently, there were other murders to add to the fun, so the disappointment was tempered by the other mysteries. Here, there is a second death, but it’s part of the solution and again, not vastly interesting.

I mentioned recently in my review of Death In Paradise, the new BBC drama, that the murderer was lucky as a few lucky happenings helped confuse the situation. There’s one incident that complicates matters here – just one – but it’s really, really odd. I think some readers might find it a little forced, to be honest, and given that the problem of the missing weapon only rears its head after a while, it seems a little odd that Ellery wouldn’t have spotted the solution earlier, as this is the only issue that he needs to resolve.

Anyway, so far, so fine, but now we come to the big problem with the book – Eva Maclure herself. I’m not a violent man in any way, shape or form, but if I could have reached into the book, grabbed her by the shoulders and yelled at her to grow up, I would have done. She’s absolutely unbearable – moping, falling for the first man who shows her interest, falling for the second man who shows her interest… and with the book written mostly from a spot just behind her head, tuned into her deepest thoughts… well, it doesn’t help. I presume the book was, like Half-Way House, serialised in a magazine that wanted the romantic elements as well as the mystery, but it got on my nerves throughout the book.

If you can stomach the Eva character, this isn’t a bad puzzle, but there’s not much to it. I can’t bring myself to recommend it except for a completist. Certainly don’t make this your first Ellery adventure.

About these ads

About Puzzle Doctor

I'm a mathematician by nature and as such have always been drawn to the logical side of things. Hence my two main hobbies being classic mysteries and logical puzzling. Oh, and cats. No logic there, I'm afraid.
This entry was posted in Ellery Queen, Locked Rooms and Impossible Murders. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to The Door Between by Ellery Queen

  1. Oh dear! This is, to my mind, one of the better stories from ‘second period’ Queen, when he/they were targeting magazine sales that in part appealed to female readers. I remember quite liking this one, not least for the subsidiary character of the tough PI which i remember finding quite amusing.

    Incidentally, this one was filmed as ELLERY QUEEN MASTER DETECTIVE starring Ralph Bellamy and Nikki Porter replacing Eva which I think you might approve of! You can view / download it online at: http://www.mevio.com/episode/107801/ellery-queen-master-detective

    • Ah, yes, Terry King. To be honest, I found his character served two purposes – firstly to serve the “romance” plot and second, to unnaturally extend the mystery. I think that’s the overall problem with this one for me – there simply isn’t enough plot for a novel. Oh, and the casual racism is even worse than usual here – against the japanese especially.

  2. Pingback: The Devil To Pay by Ellery Queen | In Search of the Classic Mystery Novel

  3. What a great site to stumble upon! I didn’t know anybody was writing about Ellery Queen these days. I agree with most of your points about this book, and by coincidence I just wrote about it myself a few days ago. Small world, huh? http://u-town.com/collins/?p=2971

  4. Pingback: ELLERY QUEEN. The Door Between (1936). « Only Detect

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s